Bill C-22, An Act to establish the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and to make consequential amendments to certain Acts (report stage amendment)
16 (1) The appropriate Minister for a department may refuse to provide information to which the Committee would, but for this section, otherwise be entitled to have access and that is under the control of that department, but only if he or she is of the opinion that (a) the information constitutes special operational information, as defined in subsection 8(1) of the Security of Information Act; and (b) provision of the information would be injurious to national security. (2) If the appropriate Minister refuses to provide information under subsection (1), he or she must inform the Committee of his or her decision and the reasons for the decision. (3) If the appropriate Minister makes the decision in respect of any of the following information, he or she must provide the decision and reasons to, (a) in the case of information under the control of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the Royal Canadian Mounted Police; (b) in the case of information under the control of the Communications Security Establishment, the Commissioner of the Communications Security Establishment; and (c) in the case of information under the control of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the Security Intelligence Review Committee.
Members who broke with their caucus
2 membersThese members cast a ballot opposite to the majority of their own caucus on this division.
- Marilyn GladuLiberalSarnia—Lambton—BkejwanongNay
- Matt JenerouxLiberalEdmonton RiverbendNay
Breakdown by party
| Caucus | Yea | Nay | Paired | No ballot | Caucus position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal | 58 | 2 | 0 | 3 | Yea |
| Conservative | 0 | 40 | 0 | 4 | Nay |
| Bloc | 0 | 5 | 0 | 2 | Nay |
| NDP | 0 | 5 | 0 | 0 | Nay |
| Green | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Nay |
| Independent | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Nay |
Every ballot
121 of 121| Member | Party | Riding | Ballot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ahmed Hussen | Liberal | York South—Weston—EtobicokeOntario | Yea |
| Alexandra Mendes | Liberal | Brossard—Saint-LambertQuebec | Yea |
| Alexandre Boulerice | Independent | Rosemont—La Petite-PatrieQuebec | Nay |
| Ali Ehsassi | Liberal | WillowdaleOntario | Yea |
| Andrew Scheer | Conservative | Regina—Qu'AppelleSaskatchewan | Did not vote |
| Angelo Iacono | Liberal | Alfred-PellanQuebec | Yea |
| Anita Vandenbeld | Liberal | Ottawa West—NepeanOntario | Yea |
| Anju Dhillon | Liberal | Dorval—Lachine—LaSalleQuebec | Yea |
| Anthony Housefather | Liberal | Mount RoyalQuebec | Yea |
| Arnold Viersen | Conservative | Peace River—WestlockAlberta | Nay |
| Bardish Chagger | Liberal | WaterlooOntario | Yea |
| Ben Lobb | Conservative | Huron—BruceOntario | Nay |
| Bernard Généreux | Conservative | Côte-du-Sud—Rivière-du-Loup—Kataskomiq—TémiscouataQuebec | Nay |
| Blaine Calkins | Conservative | Ponoka—DidsburyAlberta | Nay |
| Blake Richards | Conservative | Airdrie—CochraneAlberta | Nay |
| Bob Nault | Liberal | Kenora—Rainy RiverOntario | Yea |
| Bob Zimmer | Conservative | Prince George—Peace River—Northern RockiesBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Bobby Morrissey | Liberal | EgmontPrince Edward Island | Yea |
| Carol Hughes | NDP | Algoma—Manitoulin—KapuskasingOntario | Nay |
| Cathay Wagantall | Conservative | Yorkton—MelvilleSaskatchewan | Did not vote |
| Cheryl Gallant | Conservative | Algonquin—Renfrew—PembrokeOntario | Nay |
| Chris Bittle | Liberal | St. CatharinesOntario | Did not vote |
| Chris Warkentin | Conservative | Grande PrairieAlberta | Nay |
| Dan Albas | Conservative | Okanagan Lake West—South KelownaBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Darren Fisher | Liberal | Dartmouth—Cole HarbourNova Scotia | Yea |
| David McGuinty | Liberal | Ottawa SouthOntario | Yea |
| Dean Allison | Conservative | Niagara WestOntario | Nay |
| Dominic LeBlanc | Liberal | BeauséjourNew Brunswick | Did not vote |
| Don Davies | NDP | Vancouver KingswayBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Doug Eyolfson | Liberal | Winnipeg WestManitoba | Yea |
| Elizabeth May | Green | Saanich—Gulf IslandsBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Fayçal El-Khoury | Liberal | Laval—Les ÎlesQuebec | Yea |
| Francis Scarpaleggia | Liberal | Lac-Saint-LouisQuebec | Yea |
| François-Philippe Champagne | Liberal | Saint-Maurice—ChamplainQuebec | Yea |
| Gabriel Ste-Marie | Bloc | Joliette—ManawanQuebec | Nay |
| Garnett Genuis | Conservative | Sherwood Park—Fort SaskatchewanAlberta | Nay |
| Gary Anandasangaree | Liberal | Scarborough—Guildwood—Rouge ParkOntario | Yea |
| Geng Tan | Liberal | Don Valley NorthOntario | Yea |
| Gérard Deltell | Conservative | Louis-Saint-Laurent—AkiawenhrahkQuebec | Nay |
| Ginette Petitpas Taylor | Liberal | Moncton—DieppeNew Brunswick | Yea |
| Glen Motz | Conservative | Medicine Hat—Cardston—WarnerAlberta | Nay |
| Gord Johns | NDP | Courtenay—AlberniBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Greg Fergus | Liberal | Hull—AylmerQuebec | Yea |
| Hedy Fry | Liberal | Vancouver CentreBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Iqra Khalid | Liberal | Mississauga—Erin MillsOntario | Yea |
| Jacques Gourde | Conservative | Lévis—LotbinièreQuebec | Nay |
| James Bezan | Conservative | Selkirk—Interlake—EastmanManitoba | Nay |
| James Maloney | Liberal | Etobicoke—LakeshoreOntario | Yea |
| Jamie Schmale | Conservative | Haliburton—Kawartha LakesOntario | Nay |
| Jean-Yves Duclos | Liberal | Québec CentreQuebec | Yea |
| Jenny Kwan | NDP | Vancouver EastBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Joël Godin | Conservative | Portneuf—Jacques-CartierQuebec | Nay |
| Joël Lightbound | Liberal | Louis-HébertQuebec | Yea |
| John Barlow | Conservative | FoothillsAlberta | Nay |
| John Brassard | Conservative | Barrie South—InnisfilOntario | Nay |
| John Nater | Conservative | Perth—WellingtonOntario | Nay |
| Judy Sgro | Liberal | Humber River—Black CreekOntario | Did not vote |
| Julie Dabrusin | Liberal | Toronto—DanforthOntario | Yea |
| Julie Dzerowicz | Liberal | DavenportOntario | Yea |
| Karina Gould | Liberal | BurlingtonOntario | Yea |
| Karine Trudel | NDP | JonquièreQuebec | Nay |
| Kelly Block | Conservative | Carlton Trail—Eagle CreekSaskatchewan | Nay |
| Kelly McCauley | Conservative | Edmonton WestAlberta | Nay |
| Kerry Diotte | Conservative | Edmonton GriesbachAlberta | Nay |
| Kevin Lamoureux | Liberal | Winnipeg NorthManitoba | Yea |
| Kevin Waugh | Conservative | Saskatoon SouthSaskatchewan | Nay |
| Linda Lapointe | Liberal | Rivière-des-Mille-ÎlesQuebec | Yea |
| Louis Plamondon | Bloc | Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—AlnôbakQuebec | Nay |
| Luc Berthold | Conservative | Mégantic—L’Érable—LotbinièreQuebec | Nay |
| Luc Thériault | Bloc | MontcalmQuebec | Nay |
| Marc Miller | Liberal | Ville-Marie—Le Sud-Ouest—Île-des-SoeursQuebec | Yea |
| Marilène Gill | Bloc | Côte-Nord—Kawawachikamach—NitassinanQuebec | Nay |
| Marilyn GladuAgainst caucus | Liberal | Sarnia—Lambton—BkejwanongOntario | Nay |
| Mario Beaulieu | Bloc | La Pointe-de-l'ÎleQuebec | Did not vote |
| Mark Gerretsen | Liberal | Kingston and the IslandsOntario | Yea |
| Mark Strahl | Conservative | Chilliwack—HopeBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Matt JenerouxAgainst caucus | Liberal | Edmonton RiverbendAlberta | Nay |
| Mel Arnold | Conservative | Kamloops—Shuswap—Central RockiesBritish Columbia | Nay |
| Mélanie Joly | Liberal | Ahuntsic-CartiervilleQuebec | Yea |
| Michael Chong | Conservative | Wellington—Halton Hills NorthOntario | Did not vote |
| Michael Cooper | Conservative | St. Albert—Sturgeon RiverAlberta | Nay |
| Michelle Rempel | Conservative | Calgary Nose HillAlberta | Nay |
| Mike Lake | Conservative | Leduc—WetaskiwinAlberta | Nay |
| Pat Kelly | Conservative | Calgary CrowfootAlberta | Nay |
| Patty Hajdu | Liberal | Thunder Bay—Superior NorthOntario | Yea |
| Peter Fonseca | Liberal | Mississauga East—CooksvilleOntario | Yea |
| Peter Fragiskatos | Liberal | London CentreOntario | Yea |
| Peter Schiefke | Liberal | VaudreuilQuebec | Yea |
| Pierre Paul-Hus | Conservative | Charlesbourg—Haute-Saint-CharlesQuebec | Nay |
| Pierre Poilievre | Conservative | Battle River—CrowfootAlberta | Nay |
| Rachael Thomas | Conservative | LethbridgeAlberta | Nay |
| Randeep Sarai | Liberal | Surrey CentreBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Randy Hoback | Conservative | Prince AlbertSaskatchewan | Nay |
| René Arseneault | Liberal | Madawaska—RestigoucheNew Brunswick | Yea |
| Rhéal Fortin | Bloc | Rivière-du-NordQuebec | Nay |
| Rob Oliphant | Liberal | Don Valley WestOntario | Yea |
| Ron McKinnon | Liberal | Coquitlam—Port CoquitlamBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Ruby Sahota | Liberal | Brampton North—CaledonOntario | Yea |
| Salma Zahid | Liberal | Scarborough Centre—Don Valley EastOntario | Yea |
| Scott Reid | Conservative | Lanark—FrontenacOntario | Nay |
| Sean Casey | Liberal | CharlottetownPrince Edward Island | Yea |
| Sean Fraser | Liberal | Central NovaNova Scotia | Yea |
| Serge Cormier | Liberal | Acadie—BathurstNew Brunswick | Yea |
| Shannon Stubbs | Conservative | LakelandAlberta | Nay |
| Shaun Chen | Liberal | Scarborough NorthOntario | Yea |
| Sherry Romanado | Liberal | Longueuil—Charles-LeMoyneQuebec | Yea |
| Sonia Sidhu | Liberal | Brampton SouthOntario | Yea |
| Stéphane Lauzon | Liberal | Argenteuil—La Petite-NationQuebec | Yea |
| Stephen Fuhr | Liberal | KelownaBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Steven MacKinnon | Liberal | GatineauQuebec | Yea |
| Sukh Dhaliwal | Liberal | Surrey NewtonBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Sven Spengemann | Liberal | Mississauga—LakeshoreOntario | Yea |
| Ted Falk | Conservative | ProvencherManitoba | Nay |
| Terry Beech | Liberal | Burnaby North—SeymourBritish Columbia | Yea |
| Terry Duguid | Liberal | Winnipeg SouthManitoba | Yea |
| Terry Sheehan | Liberal | Sault Ste. Marie—AlgomaOntario | Yea |
| Todd Doherty | Conservative | Cariboo—Prince GeorgeBritish Columbia | Did not vote |
| Tom Kmiec | Conservative | Calgary ShepardAlberta | Nay |
| Wayne Long | Liberal | Saint John—KennebecasisNew Brunswick | Yea |
| Xavier Barsalou-Duval | Bloc | Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—VerchèresQuebec | Did not vote |
| Ziad Aboultaif | Conservative | Edmonton ManningAlberta | Nay |
Sources
“Did not vote” only means no ballot was recorded. Pairing, committee duty, ministerial travel and approved leave are not distinguishable in the source data, so it is not a measure of unexcused absence. Caucus position is derived by us from the individual ballots, not published by the House.