Division 12042nd Parliament, 1st sessionOct 5, 2016

2nd reading of Bill C-246, An Act to amend the Criminal Code, the Fisheries Act, the Textile Labelling Act, the Wild Animal and Plant Protection and Regulation of International and Interprovincial Trade Act and the Canada Consumer Product Safety Act (animal protection)

That the Bill be now read a second time and referred to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.

Result

Negatived

Yea

Nay

198

Paired

Members who broke with their caucus

21 members

These members cast a ballot opposite to the majority of their own caucus on this division.

Ahmed HussenLiberalYork South—Weston—EtobicokeYea
Alexandra MendesLiberalBrossard—Saint-LambertYea
Ali EhsassiLiberalWillowdaleYea
Chris BittleLiberalSt. CatharinesYea
Doug EyolfsonLiberalWinnipeg WestYea
Gary AnandasangareeLiberalScarborough—Guildwood—Rouge ParkYea
Greg FergusLiberalHull—AylmerYea
Hedy FryLiberalVancouver CentreYea
James MaloneyLiberalEtobicoke—LakeshoreYea
Joël LightboundLiberalLouis-HébertYea
John McKayLiberalScarborough EastYea
Julie DabrusinLiberalToronto—DanforthYea
Julie DzerowiczLiberalDavenportYea
Karina GouldLiberalBurlingtonYea
Mark GerretsenLiberalKingston and the IslandsYea
Michelle RempelConservativeCalgary Nose HillYea
Peter SchiefkeLiberalVaudreuilYea
Rob OliphantLiberalDon Valley WestYea
Ron McKinnonLiberalCoquitlam—Port CoquitlamYea
Stephen FuhrLiberalKelownaYea
Terry BeechLiberalBurnaby North—SeymourYea

Breakdown by party

Caucus	Yea	Nay	No ballot	Caucus position
Liberal	20	40	6	Nay
Conservative	1	35	8	Nay
Bloc	5	0	2	Yea
NDP	4	0	0	Yea
Green	0	0	1	Split
Independent	1	0	0	Yea

Every ballot

123 of 123

Member	Party	Riding	Ballot
Ahmed HussenAgainst caucus	Liberal	York South—Weston—EtobicokeOntario	Yea
Alexandra MendesAgainst caucus	Liberal	Brossard—Saint-LambertQuebec	Yea
Alexandre Boulerice	Independent	Rosemont—La Petite-PatrieQuebec	Yea
Ali EhsassiAgainst caucus	Liberal	WillowdaleOntario	Yea
Andrew Scheer	Conservative	Regina—Qu'AppelleSaskatchewan	Nay
Angelo Iacono	Liberal	Alfred-PellanQuebec	Nay
Anita Vandenbeld	Liberal	Ottawa West—NepeanOntario	Nay
Anju Dhillon	Liberal	Dorval—Lachine—LaSalleQuebec	Nay
Anthony Housefather	Liberal	Mount RoyalQuebec	Nay
Anthony Rota	Liberal	Nipissing—TimiskamingOntario	Nay
Arnold Viersen	Conservative	Peace River—WestlockAlberta	Nay
Bardish Chagger	Liberal	WaterlooOntario	Nay
Ben Lobb	Conservative	Huron—BruceOntario	Nay
Bernadette Jordan	Liberal	South Shore—St. MargaretsNova Scotia	Nay
Bernard Généreux	Conservative	Côte-du-Sud—Rivière-du-Loup—Kataskomiq—TémiscouataQuebec	Nay
Blaine Calkins	Conservative	Ponoka—DidsburyAlberta	Nay
Blake Richards	Conservative	Airdrie—CochraneAlberta	Did not vote
Bob Zimmer	Conservative	Prince George—Peace River—Northern RockiesBritish Columbia	Nay
Bobby Morrissey	Liberal	EgmontPrince Edward Island	Nay
Brian Masse	NDP	Windsor WestOntario	Yea
Cathay Wagantall	Conservative	Yorkton—MelvilleSaskatchewan	Nay
Cheryl Gallant	Conservative	Algonquin—Renfrew—PembrokeOntario	Nay
Chris BittleAgainst caucus	Liberal	St. CatharinesOntario	Yea
Chris Warkentin	Conservative	Grande PrairieAlberta	Nay
Dan Albas	Conservative	Okanagan Lake West—South KelownaBritish Columbia	Nay
Darren Fisher	Liberal	Dartmouth—Cole HarbourNova Scotia	Nay
David McGuinty	Liberal	Ottawa SouthOntario	Nay
Dean Allison	Conservative	Niagara WestOntario	Nay
Dominic LeBlanc	Liberal	BeauséjourNew Brunswick	Did not vote
Don Davies	NDP	Vancouver KingswayBritish Columbia	Yea
Doug EyolfsonAgainst caucus	Liberal	Winnipeg WestManitoba	Yea
Elizabeth May	Green	Saanich—Gulf IslandsBritish Columbia	Did not vote
Fayçal El-Khoury	Liberal	Laval—Les ÎlesQuebec	Nay
Francis Scarpaleggia	Liberal	Lac-Saint-LouisQuebec	Did not vote
François-Philippe Champagne	Liberal	Saint-Maurice—ChamplainQuebec	Nay
Gabriel Ste-Marie	Bloc	Joliette—ManawanQuebec	Did not vote
Garnett Genuis	Conservative	Sherwood Park—Fort SaskatchewanAlberta	Nay
Gary AnandasangareeAgainst caucus	Liberal	Scarborough—Guildwood—Rouge ParkOntario	Yea
Gérard Deltell	Conservative	Louis-Saint-Laurent—AkiawenhrahkQuebec	Nay
Ginette Petitpas Taylor	Liberal	Moncton—DieppeNew Brunswick	Nay
Gord Johns	NDP	Courtenay—AlberniBritish Columbia	Yea
Greg FergusAgainst caucus	Liberal	Hull—AylmerQuebec	Yea
Harold Albrecht	Conservative	Kitchener—ConestogaOntario	Nay
Hedy FryAgainst caucus	Liberal	Vancouver CentreBritish Columbia	Yea
Iqra Khalid	Liberal	Mississauga—Erin MillsOntario	Nay
Jacques Gourde	Conservative	Lévis—LotbinièreQuebec	Nay
James Bezan	Conservative	Selkirk—Interlake—EastmanManitoba	Nay
James MaloneyAgainst caucus	Liberal	Etobicoke—LakeshoreOntario	Yea
Jamie Schmale	Conservative	Haliburton—Kawartha LakesOntario	Nay
Jean-Yves Duclos	Liberal	Québec CentreQuebec	Nay
Jenny Kwan	NDP	Vancouver EastBritish Columbia	Yea
Joël Godin	Conservative	Portneuf—Jacques-CartierQuebec	Did not vote
Joël LightboundAgainst caucus	Liberal	Louis-HébertQuebec	Yea
John Barlow	Conservative	FoothillsAlberta	Did not vote
John Brassard	Conservative	Barrie South—InnisfilOntario	Nay
John McKayAgainst caucus	Liberal	Scarborough EastOntario	Yea
John Nater	Conservative	Perth—WellingtonOntario	Did not vote
Judy Sgro	Liberal	Humber River—Black CreekOntario	Nay
Julie DabrusinAgainst caucus	Liberal	Toronto—DanforthOntario	Yea
Julie DzerowiczAgainst caucus	Liberal	DavenportOntario	Yea
Karina GouldAgainst caucus	Liberal	BurlingtonOntario	Yea
Kelly Block	Conservative	Carlton Trail—Eagle CreekSaskatchewan	Nay
Kelly McCauley	Conservative	Edmonton WestAlberta	Did not vote
Kerry Diotte	Conservative	Edmonton GriesbachAlberta	Nay
Kevin Lamoureux	Liberal	Winnipeg NorthManitoba	Nay
Kevin Waugh	Conservative	Saskatoon SouthSaskatchewan	Nay
Larry Bagnell	Liberal	YukonYukon	Nay
Linda Lapointe	Liberal	Rivière-des-Mille-ÎlesQuebec	Nay
Louis Plamondon	Bloc	Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—AlnôbakQuebec	Did not vote
Luc Berthold	Conservative	Mégantic—L’Érable—LotbinièreQuebec	Nay
Luc Thériault	Bloc	MontcalmQuebec	Yea
Marc Miller	Liberal	Ville-Marie—Le Sud-Ouest—Île-des-SoeursQuebec	Nay
Marc Serré	Liberal	Nickel BeltOntario	Nay
Marilène Gill	Bloc	Côte-Nord—Kawawachikamach—NitassinanQuebec	Yea
Marilyn Gladu	Liberal	Sarnia—Lambton—BkejwanongOntario	Nay
Mario Beaulieu	Bloc	La Pointe-de-l'ÎleQuebec	Yea
Mark GerretsenAgainst caucus	Liberal	Kingston and the IslandsOntario	Yea
Mark Strahl	Conservative	Chilliwack—HopeBritish Columbia	Nay
Matt Jeneroux	Liberal	Edmonton RiverbendAlberta	Nay
Mel Arnold	Conservative	Kamloops—Shuswap—Central RockiesBritish Columbia	Nay
Mélanie Joly	Liberal	Ahuntsic-CartiervilleQuebec	Nay
Michael Chong	Conservative	Wellington—Halton Hills NorthOntario	Nay
Michael Cooper	Conservative	St. Albert—Sturgeon RiverAlberta	Nay
Michelle RempelAgainst caucus	Conservative	Calgary Nose HillAlberta	Yea
Mike Lake	Conservative	Leduc—WetaskiwinAlberta	Nay
Pat Kelly	Conservative	Calgary CrowfootAlberta	Nay
Patty Hajdu	Liberal	Thunder Bay—Superior NorthOntario	Nay
Peter Fonseca	Liberal	Mississauga East—CooksvilleOntario	Nay
Peter Fragiskatos	Liberal	London CentreOntario	Nay
Peter SchiefkeAgainst caucus	Liberal	VaudreuilQuebec	Yea
Pierre Paul-Hus	Conservative	Charlesbourg—Haute-Saint-CharlesQuebec	Nay
Pierre Poilievre	Conservative	Battle River—CrowfootAlberta	Nay
Rachael Thomas	Conservative	LethbridgeAlberta	Nay
Randeep Sarai	Liberal	Surrey CentreBritish Columbia	Nay
Randy Hoback	Conservative	Prince AlbertSaskatchewan	Nay
René Arseneault	Liberal	Madawaska—RestigoucheNew Brunswick	Nay
Rhéal Fortin	Bloc	Rivière-du-NordQuebec	Yea
Rob OliphantAgainst caucus	Liberal	Don Valley WestOntario	Yea
Ron McKinnonAgainst caucus	Liberal	Coquitlam—Port CoquitlamBritish Columbia	Yea
Ruby Sahota	Liberal	Brampton North—CaledonOntario	Did not vote
Salma Zahid	Liberal	Scarborough Centre—Don Valley EastOntario	Nay
Scott Reid	Conservative	Lanark—FrontenacOntario	Did not vote
Sean Casey	Liberal	CharlottetownPrince Edward Island	Did not vote
Sean Fraser	Liberal	Central NovaNova Scotia	Nay
Serge Cormier	Liberal	Acadie—BathurstNew Brunswick	Nay
Shannon Stubbs	Conservative	LakelandAlberta	Nay
Shaun Chen	Liberal	Scarborough NorthOntario	Nay
Sherry Romanado	Liberal	Longueuil—Charles-LeMoyneQuebec	Did not vote
Sonia Sidhu	Liberal	Brampton SouthOntario	Nay
Stéphane Lauzon	Liberal	Argenteuil—La Petite-NationQuebec	Nay
Stephen FuhrAgainst caucus	Liberal	KelownaBritish Columbia	Yea
Steven MacKinnon	Liberal	GatineauQuebec	Did not vote
Sukh Dhaliwal	Liberal	Surrey NewtonBritish Columbia	Nay
Sven Spengemann	Liberal	Mississauga—LakeshoreOntario	Nay
Ted Falk	Conservative	ProvencherManitoba	Nay
Terry BeechAgainst caucus	Liberal	Burnaby North—SeymourBritish Columbia	Yea
Terry Duguid	Liberal	Winnipeg SouthManitoba	Nay
Terry Sheehan	Liberal	Sault Ste. Marie—AlgomaOntario	Nay
Todd Doherty	Conservative	Cariboo—Prince GeorgeBritish Columbia	Nay
Tom Kmiec	Conservative	Calgary ShepardAlberta	Did not vote
Wayne Long	Liberal	Saint John—KennebecasisNew Brunswick	Nay
Xavier Barsalou-Duval	Bloc	Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—VerchèresQuebec	Yea
Ziad Aboultaif	Conservative	Edmonton ManningAlberta	Did not vote

Sources

Related billC-246

Official recordourcommons.ca ↗

BallotsOpenParliament ↗

“Did not vote” only means no ballot was recorded. Pairing, committee duty, ministerial travel and approved leave are not distinguishable in the source data, so it is not a measure of unexcused absence. Caucus position is derived by us from the individual ballots, not published by the House.